| NAME and LIFESPAN | SERVICE | LENGTH |
| Rev. Elam C. Clark (?) | part time | 1828 to 1830 |
| Rev. Burr Baldwin (1789 – 1880) | settled | 1830 to 1834 |
| Rev. Dr. Willis Lord (1809 – 1888) | settled | 1834 to 1838 |
| Rev. Dr. John Woodbridge (1784 – 1869) | settled | 1839 to 1842 |
| Rev. Alexander Leadbetter (1800? – ?) | settled | 1844 to 1849 |
| Rev. Joseph Addison Saxton (1810 – 1902) | settled | 1851 to 1852 |
| Rev. Franklin Augustus Spencer (1811 – 1884) | settled | 1853 to 1863 |
| Rev. James Bradford Cleaveland (1821 – 1889) | settled | 1865 to 1867 |
| Rev. Alpheus Winter (1838 – 1891) | settled | 1868 to 1869 |
| Rev. Sanford Smith Martyn (1839 – 1919) | settled | 1870 to 1874 |
| Rev. Frederick H. Adams (1834 – 1899) | settled | 1875 to 1887 |
| Rev. John Philo Hawley (1833 – 1898) | year to year | 1888 to 1897 |
| Rev. Dr. Frank Sherman Brewer (1869 – 1937) | settled | 1898 to 1906 |
| Rev. Dr. Edward O. Grisbrook (1866 – 1944) | settled | 1907 to 1918 |
| Rev. Edward B. Williston (?) | settled | 1919 to 1920 |
| Rev. Hubert S. Stafford (?) | settled | 1920 to 1925 |
| Rev. Arthur E. Paterson (1884 – 1981) | settled | 1925 to 1927 |
| Rev. Robert Waldemar Putsch (1904 – 1981) | settled | 1927 to 1930 |
| Rev. Frank Landolt (1906 – 1999) | settled | 1931 to 1934 |
| Rev. Henry Ammen Peck (1901 – 1971) | settled | 1935 to 1941 |
| Rev. Ellis E. Peterson (?) | settled | 1942 to 1943 |
| Rev. Dr. Archie Goff Bedford (? – 2000) | settled | 1943 to 1945 |
| Rev. Glyn Rosser (1907 – 1951) | settled | 1945 to 1951 |
| Rev. Sumner Asgood (?) | interim | 1951 to 1952 |
| Rev. Dr. Joseph Novotny (1886 – 1966) | settled | 1952 to 1956 |
| Rev. Murray Sleeper (1920 – 1983) | settled | 1957 to 1963 |
| Rev. Graham D. Child (? – 1998 or 1999) | settled | 1964 to 1977 |
| Revs. Dale & Dolly Bond | settled | 1977 to 1981 |
| Rev. Dr. Harry L. Peatt (1940 – ) | part time | 1981 to 1985 |
| Rev. Marshall Hughes (1941 – ) | settled | 1985 to 1992 |
| Rev. Doretta Clark (1957 – ) | settled | 1994 to 2000 |
| Rev. Dr. Gregory Dawson (1957 – | settled | 2000 to 2007 |
| Rev. Stan Youngberg | interim | 2007 to 2008 |
| Rev. Margret Hofmeister | part time | 2009 to 2017 |
| Rev. John Madsen-Bibeau | interim | 2017 to 2019 |
| Rev. Marcia Cox | interim | 2019 to 2020 |
| Pulpit Supply | | 2020 to 2022 |
| Rev. Kristie Rubendunst | designated | 2022 to 2024 |
| Pulpit Supply | | 2024 to present |
North Congregational Church 